Criminological Theories Evaluation Essay


Many Surveys and analysis present details about the prevalence of substance use within the Victoria neighborhood. Examples of those sources embrace the nationwide drug technique family surveys, which report the usage of hashish and different unlawful medication (Livingston et al., 2020). Drug offenses are contained within the Drug act of 1981, which stipulates substances that people can not possess below any scenario and dependence on medication (Susan & Georgina, 2018). The laws offers varied penalties for portions of medication concerned whereas it is usually an offense to interact in drug-related crimes in Victoria. This essay argues that pressure idea can clarify youth drug issues equivalent to poor backgrounds; the paper focuses on evaluating the criminological mannequin and supporting its limitations with retreatism and labeling fashions for in-depth insights.

We will write a customized Essay on Criminological Theories Evaluation particularly for you
for less than $16.05 $11/web page

807 licensed writers on-line

Learn More

The Problem and Background

Young persons are persistently substance customers and sometimes expertise an array of crime-related points. The drawback of drug use by youth is a significate situation within the Victoria neighborhood, as shall be mentioned on this paragraph drawing assist from media reviews, statistics, and case research. Getting right into a battle with unlawful medication below the age restrict is why younger folks face authorized conflicts in Victoria. Offenses concerned embrace public intoxication, and buying or promoting medication which is towards the legislation. Reports present that the proportion of younger offenders with a excessive variety of incidents has risen, and about 17% of victims are below 25 (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2019; Sallybanks, 2021). The trigger and results of younger individual offending and the state of Victoria’s youth justice system have grow to be a topic of broad debate after a sequence of violent circumstances in justice facilities.

The nature of youth offenders and offending locations stress on society, particularly within the justice system. Victoria has lengthy been thought of a pacesetter in youth justice, with minimal circumstances of younger folks crimes or serving custodial sentences than Australian jurisdiction (Antolak-Saper, 2020). Evidence factors that few youths have offending yearly. However, a small however rising cohort of younger folks engages in drug-related behaviors equivalent to violence regardless of the optimistic developments (Antolak-Saper, 2020). Youth justice is deemed a fancy situation that entails essential areas of public coverage, together with the neighborhood security and human rights of younger people (Hettiarachchi et al., 2018). Typically, youth justice is completely different from mainstream or prison justice on account of distinctive circumstances and offending content material. The trigger and impact of youth offenses in Victoria have grow to be a topic of debate widespread after a violent incident witnessed within the justice middle.

Although diversion is essential in decreasing re-offending by youths, entry to diversion is restricted someway in the neighborhood, particularly for younger adults in rural areas of Victoria. The unprecedented variety of youths in remand creates vital challenges in managing facilities and making the rehabilitation course of difficult for younger ones. Studies by the Victorian Ombudsman and the Commissioner for Children and Young folks have revealed issues about youth justice programs and coverings of younger individuals held therein (Phelan, 2019). Investigation exhibits that youths have been subjected to situations that breach rights as supplied by the constitution of human rights and accountability 2006 (Antolak-Saper, 2020). Further evaluation of points dealing with younger folks in Victoria exhibits that the issues will not be distinctive. For instance, the overrepresentation of indigenous folks within the youth justice system displays a multilayer of disadvantages and marginalization of some teams (Antolak-Saper, 2020). Some theories equivalent to pressure and labeling can level to this situation as a number one issue of drug use on account of discrimination, prejudice, neglect, and lack of supportive sources for minority teams.

Evaluation of Strain Theory

The pressure idea is a sociological and criminology mannequin that may assist perceive why youth drug offense equivalent to drug dealing happens. The mannequin asserts that some pressures or stressors induce the probability of committing a criminal offense, and so they can result in detrimental feelings equivalent to anger or frustrations. Consequently, feelings create stress for some actions, and committing a criminal offense is a possible response. For instance, Youths in Victoria interact in drug dealing on account of social elements equivalent to lack of earnings and schooling or poor backgrounds. Studies from Melbourne’s companies level out that about 43% of homeless populations present drug-related issues, together with alcoholism (Antolak-Saper, 2020). Applying pressure idea, such an issue with dad and mom can lead younger folks to undergo detrimental penalties by observing dad and mom’ drug issues.

The core of pressure idea is that detrimental feelings or relationships with folks and experiences produce stress that have to be managed. Instead of 1 common pressure in an individual, the mannequin reveals that there might be a number of main sources of pressure that lead somebody into unhealthy actions (Phelan, 2019). For instance, failure to satisfy valued targets and disjunction between precise outcomes and expectations may be irritating. The removing of positively valued stimuli that an individual possesses, such because the loss of life of a beloved one, may escalate stress build-up (Phelan, 2019). Another inferred supply of pressure is a presentation with negatively valued stimuli equivalent to abuse. The most perceived behavioral options are retaliatory and escapist, equivalent to involvement in medication to alleviate displeasure from dangerous detrimental emotions.

Furthermore, folks’s behaviors can considerably be influenced by the upbringing course of. According to Pedalono and Frailing (2018), human improvement is formed by what people encounter or expertise within the surroundings, and maybe essentially the most essential classes are discovered from households. Examples of different programs that form folks embrace childcare, authorized, and schooling. Such elements are contributing to shaping behaviors from the affect they trigger by means of their presence in the neighborhood. In Melbourne, youths who should not have higher entry to schooling programs are susceptible to drug issues equivalent to dealing, utilizing, or trafficking (Rickwood et al., 2019). The pressure mannequin explains why such behaviors are occurring, leading to prison offenses.

Get your 100% unique paper on any matter completed
in as little as 3 hours
Learn More

Hidden social elements from the upbringings course of information folks’s actions and decision-making. Social psychology explains how folks use social actions as sources of particulars, cues, and path on the right way to behave. In this angle, research level out that behaviors are merchandise of conditions and personalities. In situationism, folks’s actions are ruled by the rapid surroundings or environment, in contrast to the notion of disposition which asserts that inside elements decide behaviors (Phelan,2019). As directed by pressure idea, exterior forces embrace social assist, which lacks within the Victoria neighborhood to assist younger folks indulging in offense and unhealthy practices. Moreover, the social scenario mannequin offers an summary of the right way to think about how financial drawback impacts household functioning and kids’s improvement.

Economic elements affect households and impose strains, such that lack of finance creates a burden to folks in elevating kids within the desired manner. Some research have identified that kids whose households are lifted out of poverty present conduct issues. Research describes the first fashions for visioning how financial elements affect households (Couch, 2017). For occasion, the household stress and interactionist fashions are key frameworks to grasp how behaviors are constructed. Due to monetary stress, adults can grow to be depressed, sullen, and offended with each other, with rising conflicts that always lead to harsh inconsistent parenting or whole withdrawal (Couch, 2017). For adolescents, such implies a rise in dangerous actions and fewer developments in competencies that may defend them from posed dangers.

Therefore, pressure idea is related in supporting that youths’ drug dealing is because of exterior forces that people encounter when rising up in environments such because the Victoria neighborhood. Criminal acts are engaged to decrease or escape from strains and search vengeance towards stress sources or different associated targets. The total goal of dealing medication, in line with pressure idea, is to alleviate detrimental feelings (Peck et al., 2018; TeijĂłn-Alcalá & Birkbeck, 2019). For occasion, this mannequin explains why youngsters who’re raised by alcoholic or drug addict dad and mom on the streets take pleasure in drug dealing to counter the emotional struggling of guardian points. Also, unemployment could make them interact in unlawful actions to earn a dwelling or devour medication to really feel higher.

In the identical case as different theories, the pressure mannequin attracts vital criticism regarding its limitations in explaining a variety of things attributing to particular behaviors. Too a lot emphasis on this idea is positioned on particulars of overrepresentations of minority teams (Pedalono & Frailing, 2018). Therefore, this asserts that people concerned in drug offenses are these from decrease lessons or minority teams. On the opposite, that will not be the case since, in line with different frameworks equivalent to retreatism, younger folks’s behaviors can emanate from rebel and conformity (Pedalono & Frailing, 2018). Typically, younger folks desire to be acknowledged and accepted in social teams in the course of the adolescent stage of improvement. In the method, they could interact in practices that different folks do to accumulate an analogous identification or standing.

Strain idea assumes that individuals will commit crimes due to pressure and focuses on the exterior features of youth drug issues. On the opposite hand, the retreatism mannequin tends to develop on the latter’s limitation by mentioning particular person issues. A major situation within the Melbourne neighborhood in Victoria is homelessness which determines youth drug offenses. From research, greater than 5000 younger Victorians spend nights with out the consolation of the security of their very own house, in line with nationwide census reviews (Couch, 2017). Homelessness in Melbourne takes varied kinds equivalent to major, secondary or tertiary, and causes of this embrace abuse, household violence, unemployment, drug, and alcohol abuse (Phelan, 2019). The Australian Bureau of Statistics exhibits that the 2016 census knowledge confirms many younger folks aged 12 to 25 with out protected locations (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2018). The youth homelessness disaster connects with the issue of drug offenses by means of self-imposed behaviors as comforts.

The Retreatism mannequin entails giving up on targets and the means to accumulate them. People usually drop out of society and adapt to new cultural norms or values. Retreats can flip into deviant behaviors to pursue broadly accepted social targets. For occasion, in Victoria or Melbourne neighborhood, individuals who promote unlawful medication have rejected the culturally acceptable technique of incomes (Pedalono & Frailing, 2018). In the scenario the place younger persons are unable to finish schooling and attain aspired targets, they struggle different means for maintenance. While they might nonetheless be attending college and finding out, they could have little hope of being tutorial achievers. Consequently, they outline different means to make social modifications and get into the protest scene.

Concerning the problem of homelessness, an individual with out a house is a definitive instance of retreatism. For occasion, when people lack the institutional means to stay their targets and get jobs to maintain themselves, they grow to be inclined to strive different means to achieve the specified goals (MacNeill et al., 2020). For instance, impulsivity in youth in Melbourne is a elementary character trait that’s recognized as a danger issue for substance use. Addicted teenagers assign a low worth to delayed rewards than rapid ones. Consequently, extreme desire for fast rewards regardless of the related impacts, equivalent to conflicts with legislation enforcement, results in dependancy conduct. According to (Antolak-Saper, 2020), the overwhelming majority of younger offenders within the Victoria prison justice system present a excessive report of drug abuse ushering in an dependancy drawback. Thus, retreatism explains how drug offense happens on account of particular person imposed behaviors of dependancy than exterior influences such because the surroundings.

We will write a customized Essay on Criminological Theories Evaluation particularly for you!
Get your first paper with 15% OFF
Learn More

The limitation of pressure idea in explaining youths’ criminological points in Victoria is the dearth of concentrate on how neighborhood members understand drug customers. The labeling idea informs how people view criminals in society and might attribute conduct change by means of self-conception. Viewing youths in Melbourne as criminals and never folks in want of assist from drug issues topic them to substance reliance to counter prejudice, stigma, and rejection. In drug dealing, offenses equivalent to utilizing unlawful substances and violent behaviors happen, inflicting a battle with the legislation.

In the period of social management, labeling troubles younger folks in response to the stigma of criminalized identities. One consequence of the social means of stigma is diminished possibilities of self-development (Teijón-Alcalá & Birkbeck, 2019). Low vanity and restricted progress alternatives are prone to be pressure elements that flip youths into medication and crime. The affiliation between labels and stereotyping is documented, as impacts of labeling are famous on emotional reactions. Stigmatized folks detect feelings of anger, sympathy, worry, and anxiousness. The emotional responses can subsequently form behaviors (Teijón-Alcalá & Birkbeck, 2019). Labeling idea is a well-liked mannequin because it has reached a number of folks and is well known as a proof for deviant and prison practices. The mannequin implies a coverage of non-intervention in communities equivalent to Victoria and Melbourne. Instead of perceiving youths as deviant and drug addicts, sources must be availed to assist their improvement. Labeling calls into query actions or the existence of youth welfare, probation administration, and policing.

The component of labeling is a social assemble of deviance and crimes. According to Riveret et al. (2018), how people view themselves is socially constructed and might form younger folks’s conduct within the fallacious or upright manner. Embarking on supportive approaches equivalent to packages to assist youths from drug dealing issues is an efficient method to counter labeling and prison offenses. For instance, Melbourne and rural Victoria present drug outreach helps tailor-made to residential and home-based withdrawals (Shirley, 2017). Such intervention may assist Victoria counter the rising problems with teenage offenders. Also, ex-offenders may be helped to safe living-wage employment. Securing well-paying work can support prisoners launched from jails to stay crime-free as soon as they return to their societies.

In response to youth drug offenses in Victoria, a number of measures have been thought of counteractive approaches. Some proponents of particular actions declare that teenagers breaking the legislation by partaking in dangerous behaviors may be compelled into necessary residential drug remedies by kids’s courts. Tough however compassionate plans have to be formulated, together with sending younger folks to obligatory rehabilitation facilities. Most younger offenders in Victoria’s prison justice system have a historical past of drug use, and most teenagers report back to have been below the affect when partaking in illegal practices (Susan & Georgina, 2018). Thus, there’s a vital want to chop the reason for deviance, rebel, and crimes by addressing the drug drawback. The Australian first plan relies on the courts’ method to issuing therapeutic orders to younger folks (Susan & Georgina, 2018). Parents have to be concerned within the plan as assist devices and schooling are supplied as a part of the packages.

Preferably, the primary focus must be addressing programs and elements that lead younger folks to drug abuse and crimes. Theories may be adopted to direct potential elements that flip youths into unlawful and unhealthy practices (Susan & Georgina, 2018). For instance, using pressure and labeling idea will reinforce the notion of creating supportive packages in the neighborhood to assist victims and the final inhabitants of younger individuals in danger. The neighborhood focus in Victoria and Melbourne wants to focus on hurt discount and provide by means of seizing medication, and arresting and prosecuting sellers (Susan & Georgina, 2018). The authorities should preserve a up to date method reflecting the complicated nature of the drug situation in society. Traditional strategies of drug policing have been grounded in enforcement exercise, however analysis factors to the emergence of latest views on the issue.

In conclusion, this paper has argued that pressure idea helps perceive Victoria’s criminological drawback however has limitations in protection because it focuses on environmental elements. The retreatism mannequin explores the problem of youth drug offenses by positing that people are the explanation they take medication and topic themselves to legislation enforcement on account of character traits and stresses. Furthermore, the labeling idea expands data of youth drug offenses by asserting that the neighborhood’s notion of drug customers compels them to detrimental behaviors on account of rejection, stigma, or prejudice.


Antolak-Saper, N. (2020). The Adultification of the Youth Justice System: The Victorian Experience. Law in Context. A Socio-legal Journal, 37(1), 1-15. Web.

Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2018). Census of Population and Housing: Estimating Homelessness. Australian Bureau of Statistics. Web.

Not certain should you can write a paper on Criminological Theories Evaluation by your self? We might help you
for less than $16.05 $11/web page
Learn More

Couch, J. (2017). Neither right here nor there’: refugee younger folks and homelessness in Australia. Children and Youth Services Review, 74(C), 1-7. Web.

Hettiarachchi, L. V., Kinner, S. A., Tibble, H., & Borschmann, R. (2018). Self-harm amongst younger folks detained within the youth justice system in Sri Lanka. International journal of environmental analysis and public well being, 15(2), 209-219. Web.

Livingston, M., Holmes, J., Oldham, M., Vashishtha, R., & Pennay, A. (2020). Trends within the sequence of first alcohol, hashish and cigarette use in Australia, 2001–2016. Drug and alcohol dependence, 207(1). 1-21. Web.

MacNeill, T., O’Connor, C., Frederick, T., & James-Charles, E. (2021). From pressure idea to the capability to aspire: A contribution to the cultural political economic system of improvement. Community Development, 1-19. Web.

Peck, J. H., Childs, Ok. Ok., Jennings, W. G., & Brady, C. M. (2018). General pressure idea, despair, and substance use: Results from a nationally consultant, longitudinal pattern of White, African-American, and Hispanic adolescents and younger adults. Journal of Child & Adolescent Substance Abuse, 27(1), 11-28. Web.

Pedalono, J., & Frailing, Ok. (2018). General Strain Theory and Prescription Drug Misuse amongst Honors Students. Journal of the National Collegiate Honors Council, 19(1), 85-103. Web.

Phelan, M. (2019). Crime & justice analysis 2019. Australian Institute of Criminology. Web.

Rickwood, D., Paraskakis, M., Quin, D., Hobbs, N., Ryall, V., Trethowan, J., & McGorry, P. (2019). Australia’s innovation in youth psychological well being care: the headspace Centre mannequin. Early Intervention in Psychiatry, 13(1), 159-166. Web.

Riveret, R., Baroni, P., Gao, Y., Governatori, G., Rotolo, A., & Sartor, G. (2018). A labelling framework for probabilistic argumentation. Annals of arithmetic and synthetic intelligence, 83(1), 21-71. Web.

Sallybanks, J. (2021). What works in lowering younger folks’s involvement in crime? Australian Institute of Criminology. Web.

Shirley, Ok. (2017). The Cautious Approach: Police cautions and the influence on youth reoffending. Crime Statistics Agency, 9, 1-23. Web.

Susan, G., & Georgina, F. (2018). Predictions on future Victorian illicit drug market influences. Australian Institute of Criminology. Web.

Teijón-Alcalá, M., & Birkbeck, C. (2019). Victimization, crime propensity, and deviance: a multinational check of common pressure idea. Journal of latest prison justice, 35(4), 410-430. Web.

Looking for this or a Similar Assignment? Order a Paper Now