Mental Health Information Disclosure and Moral Panic Research Paper



The connection between the psychological problems with a person and the chance of them creating the patterns of legal conduct is a somewhat questionable space (Meloy & Hoffmann, 2013). However, viewing the folks with psychological disadvantages as doable perpetrators is prone to battle with folks’s idea of social justice, subsequently, triggering a rise within the ethical panic charges. Therefore, to facilitate the wellbeing of the residents and on the similar time ensure that the rights of the mentally deprived shouldn’t be infringed, one should think about the connection between the event of legal behaviors, the progress of psychological issues, and the position that the ethical panic charges within the society have on folks’s notion of individuals with psychological points as doable criminals.

We will write a customized Research Paper on Mental Health Information Disclosure and Moral Panic particularly for you
for less than $16.05 $11/web page

807 licensed writers on-line

Learn More

Research Question

The examine in query is geared toward checking whether or not the disclosure of knowledge concerning folks with psychological points as doable perpetrators needs to be seen as admissible in modern society is the first analysis query to be answered in the midst of the evaluation. The analysis query, subsequently, may be put within the following method:

Do folks with psychological well being points show the behavioral patterns that may be outlined as those much like these of perpetrators, and the way does the difficulty of the ethical panic issue within the technique of vilifying the mentally impaired as doable criminals?


Although the examine beneath evaluation can’t be seen as the last word device for proving both innocence or potential hazard of individuals with psychological points, it should nonetheless shed some gentle on the subject material. Thus, the analysis may be seen as an try to immediate a change within the present idea of social justice. By pointing to the connection between psychological points and legal conduct – or the shortage thereof – the analysis will set the inspiration for a change.

Literature Review

People with Mental Health Issues as Perpetrators

Society has at all times displayed the tendency of viewing folks with psychological points as a supply of constant risk (Gold & Simon, 2015). While admittedly impressed by prejudice and never essentially relevant to any occasion of a psychological dysfunction, the connection between the inclination to legal conduct and the event of a psychological dysfunction has been explored and acknowledged as evident by quite a lot of researchers (Large, Ryan, Callaghan, Paton, & Singh, 2013). The causes for the above attitudes are fairly comprehensible. Since mentally challenged individuals are susceptible to dealing with fewer authorized repercussions and having much less duty for his or her actions because of their well being points, they are often seen as doable perpetrators. Moreover, the actual fact that the above members of the American society don’t totally understand the results of their actions makes one doubt whether or not they’re able to limiting themselves to the socially admissible behavioral patterns and abstaining from creating legal ones.

Moral Panic vs. the Actual Danger

One should admit, although, that the phenomenon of ethical panic performs an enormous position in vilifying folks with psychological issues (Paterson, McIntosh, Wilkinson, McComish, & Smith, 2012). Moral panic is usually outlined because the state of affairs, wherein “a condition, episode, person or group of persons emerges to become defined as a threat to societal values and interest” (Falkof, 2015, p. 47). Therefore, it may be assumed that ethical panic, when strengthened with the assistance of a particular supply, corresponding to media, might have an effect on the idea of social justice. In different phrases, ethical panic concerning the doable risk that mentally challenged folks supposedly pose to society might form the present idea of social justice. As a end result, folks with psychological points might change into simply vilified, and their intentions may be interpreted as socially unacceptable.

Researches level to the truth that ethical panic has a really highly effective impact on folks’s notion of social justice: “Social action, social justice, and critical issue arguments appear to have benefitted most from the trickle-down” (Gehrke & Keith, 2014, p. 87), because the evaluation of a equally controversial situation of media violence has proven. On the one hand, the idea of ethical panic has little to do with the issue concerning the remedy of mentally incapacitated folks as potential criminals. On the opposite hand, the moral implications of the above resolution are very prone to have a tangible impact on the ethical material of society. By assuming that mentally unstable folks and folks with psychological well being points pose a severe risk to society as doable criminals, one might create an impression of holding prejudices in opposition to the desired denizens of the inhabitants (Hartley-McAndrew & Crawford, 2016). The above assumption conflicts with the rules of democracy that the present American society is constructed on. There is a risk that the given assumption will result in the event of social moods that will prohibit the freedoms of the desired members of the U.S. inhabitants. One may declare that the phenomenon beneath evaluation can’t be deemed as totally unfavourable as it might function the technique of stopping the precise crime from occurring.

Get your 100% unique paper on any matter carried out
in as little as 3 hours
Learn More

Tools for Managing the Related Threats

While the means for addressing the difficulty above will not be but outlined clearly, a spread of methods for managing the event of prejudice and averting the specter of victimization together with the one in every of an assault from a mentally unstable individual, have been prompt.

First and most evident, consciousness should be raised in order that the knowledge concerning the subject material may very well be made out there to all these involved. As a end result, the consequences of ethical panic are going to be lowered considerably. Even although the hyperlink between the event of legal conduct and the existence of particular psychological well being points is but to be examined, it’s essential that individuals ought to educate themselves in regards to the situation. Consequently, a mass marketing campaign geared toward elevating consciousness is usually seen as a doable device.

Risk Rates and the Means of Addressing Them

Because of the anomaly of the subject material and the shortage of readability concerning the identification of potential malefactors amongst mentally unstable folks, the danger charges can’t be outlined with a major quantity of precision.

Methodology Themes

The analysis beneath evaluation is favored carefully to quite a lot of themes so far as its strategies are involved.

Theme 1

The innovativeness of the examine may be seen as the first theme to be addressed with regards to discussing the analysis. As ti has been pressured above, the examine beneath evaluation explores the areas that haven’t but been addressed totally as a result of obscurity of the subject material and the potential moral implications that it’d set off. Therefore, although addressed in a number of latest research, the issue of psychological well being points and the unwillingness of individuals to attach the subject material to the rising crime charges because of ethical panic nonetheless wants additional exploration.

Theme 2

Another theme that’s carefully linked to the methodology of the paper, the difficulty concerning the topicality of the examine must be addressed. Although the issue of victimization of individuals with psychological points can’t be deemed as essential at current, a number of research level to the truth that the subject material wants additional evaluation (Kaszeta, 2014). On the one hand, the worry for private security, which individuals expertise when contemplating the likelihood for sufferers with psychological points to be susceptible to legal conduct, is comprehensible. On the opposite hand, claiming that individuals with psychological deficiencies usually tend to commit crimes means victimizing them and, thus, depriving them of their fundamental human rights.

Theme 3

In this respect the speculation of legal conduct must be addressed as one of many parts of methodology – or, to be extra particular, the theoretical framework that the analysis evaluation goes to be primarily based on. At this level, the truth that the variety of legal conduct theories is somewhat huge must be introduced up. As a rule, organic, sociological, and conventional legal conduct theories are recognized. As the names of the theories above counsel, the organic one tends to view legal conduct as intrinsic because of a particular set of organic traits, whereas the sociological one makes an attempt viewing the issue from the attitude of the social interactions. In different phrases, in distinction to the previous, the latter suggests that individuals, typically, and psychological sufferers, particularly, begin committing crimes because of the affect that their social setting has on them. The conventional legal conduct idea, in its flip, assumes that the legal conduct needs to be seen because the affect of a mix of the organic and social components. (Adler, Mueller, & Laufer, 2012).

We will write a customized Research Paper on Mental Health Information Disclosure and Moral Panic particularly for you!
Get your first paper with 15% OFF
Learn More

Theme 4

Another theme that may be linked to the methodology, the idea of a survey because the device for information retrieval may be reviewed.


Seeing that the analysis to be carried out seeks the reply to the query concerning the relations that may be outlined as qualitative, there isn’t any tangible have to quantify the output. Thus, it will likely be cheap to imagine {that a} qualitative analysis design is the only option for the paper. To reply the query above, subsequently, one must think about qualitative relationships between the dependent (i.e., the notion of individuals with psychological points as doable criminals by the society) and the impartial (i.e., the facility of ethical panic) variables.

The survey talked about above can be used as the first supply for retrieving the info from the goal inhabitants. 120 folks can be chosen to take part within the analysis and be supplied with survey questions to reply to. The surveys can be distributed electronically; nevertheless, previous to retrieving responses from the members, one must present the latter with a consent kind that they must fill in in order that their solutions may very well be used for the examine. As far because the folks beneath age are involved, their mother and father or guardians must think about signing the consent kind.

The survey outcomes can be sampled with the assistance of the random sampling method. The above strategy will contribute to the promotion of objectivity in analysis as it should assist find the solutions that aren’t linked to one another and, subsequently, present an unbiased illustration of the state of affairs. It is assumed {that a} random sampling of 20 responses will suffice for an all-embracive evaluation.

The coding method can be used to find the required data. A taxonomy of codes that can assist establish sure patterns within the responses of the members can be developed. It is recommended that the codes corresponding to “moral panic,” “criminal development,” “etiological factors,” and so on. must be included into the taxonomy in order that the knowledge may very well be organized in probably the most environment friendly method and that right conclusions may very well be made. The idea of etiological components introduced up above may be outlined because the issue that served because the pivoting level of the issue growth (Stevens, 2013). In different phrases, it has a direct relation to the subject material because it helps acquire a greater perception on the problems concerning the event of legal behavioral patterns in folks with psychological well being impairments.

Identifying the codes that happen probably the most regularly within the responses of the surveys created, one is prone to obtain sufficient information wanted to both verify or subvert the speculation in regards to the situation in query. It is anticipated that the examine will return the outcomes that present the deplorable results of ethical panic in relation to well being points and criminology.

The additional evaluation, subsequently, can be geared toward finding the frequency of the prevalence of explicit codes. The latter, of their flip, can be interpreted in order that the relationships between the important thing variables may very well be recognized and that the analysis query may very well be answered. At current, it’s anticipated {that a} vital charge of correlation between the perspective in the direction of the difficulty of psychological well being and the more and more excessive charges of ethical panic can be recognized. The hyperlink between the crimes dedicated and the variety of folks affected by particular well being points, in its flip, is extremely unlikely to be represented. The results that the present ethical stance on the remedy of individuals with psychological impairments and the criminalization thereof, in its flip, is prone to be positioned comparatively quick.


It needs to be famous, although, that the examine beneath evaluation has its limitations, the pattern measurement being the important thing one. Since the analysis may be outlined as time-bound, finishing up an enormous evaluation of the subject material together with a bigger variety of samples is inconceivable. Therefore, the outcomes of the examine must be approximated.

Not positive for those who can write a paper on Mental Health Information Disclosure and Moral Panic by your self? We might help you
for less than $16.05 $11/web page
Learn More

In addition, there are excessive chance charges for the outcomes of the examine to be affected by the non-public stance of the analysis on the subject material. Even although the examine beneath evaluation doesn’t use interviews and adopts the surveying method as an alternative, the probabilities for the outcomes of the evaluation to be affected by the non-public convictions of the creator of the paper are somewhat excessive. The charges of the analysis objectivity may be enhanced by adopting a inflexible methodology method.

Internal and External Validity

Validity is a extremely essential idea in analysis, particularly in its experiment-based type. The time period ‘validity’ denotes the extent to which a given examine is logical and lucid, so far as its factual and causal claims are involved (Maxfield & Babbie, 2014, p. 127). When one evaluates the deserves of a analysis examine, they regularly talk about its inner and exterior validity: whereas each varieties are equally essential, they do, nonetheless, regularly current a trade-off in experimental analysis.

Internal validity refers back to the examine’s personal consistency, logic, and soundness. Thus, a researcher that produces an internally legitimate examine ensures that the logic that they apply to the analysis topics is constant and clear. Typically, inner validity is maximized when the researcher has higher management over the experiment and may declare with higher certainty that the conclusions of their examine are, in reality, dependable. For occasion, a researcher claims that victimization is the main predictor of future engagement in violent crime. If they will isolate different variables that will have an effect on this hyperlink of their examine pattern – as an illustration, the socioeconomic standing of the respondents – then they produce a extra internally legitimate examine.

However, the extra management the researcher workout routines over the examine, the extra it undermines its exterior validity because the experiment’s circumstances change into considerably synthetic. External validity refers back to the extent to which the examine’s findings are generalizable in respect to the overall inhabitants, and never simply to the examine’s pattern. A researcher making an attempt to maximise the examine’s exterior validity will attempt to conduct an experiment in additional pure circumstances – nevertheless, the much less management a researcher has over the examine, the much less internally legitimate its findings are typically.


The connection between psychological well being and the event of behavioral patterns that may be outlined as legal wants additional evaluation as groundless assumptions made within the specified space might result in the infringement of individuals’s rights. Indeed, the victimization of mentally impaired folks is in opposition to the present rules of democracy because it jeopardizes the protection of the goal denizens of the inhabitants. However, other than affecting folks with psychological deficiencies, the desired situation additionally poses a major concern to the wellbeing of the remainder of the U.S. inhabitants. In case the supposition concerning the connection between the psychological well being of an individual and their inclination towards a sure legal conduct sample is right, the shortage of motion towards facilitating the protection of the remainder of the U.S. residents might result in drastic outcomes.

Therefore, an in depth evaluation of the subject material should be carried out. A examine will try at answering the query concerning the connection between the idea of ethical panic and the method of figuring out folks with psychological points as doable criminals. In different phrases, the examine will give attention to figuring out how the phenomenon of ethical panic shapes folks’s notion of psychological sufferers as doable criminals.

The significance of the issue is kind of apparent. In the period that heralds democracy as the inspiration for the event of social justice, the difficulty of victimization of psychological sufferers should be addressed as the topic of concern. Moreover, the wellbeing of the folks which are affected by the difficulty is questioned till the issue is resolved.

It is anticipated that the present stance on the difficulty of psychological sufferers and their relation to the present crime charges can be reviewed from the attitude of the modern social justice. Te examine will, subsequently, shed some gentle on whether or not the phenomenon of ethical panic prevents folks from victimizing mentally impaired sufferers, whether or not the society judges the latter, or whether or not an goal viewpoint with reference to the analysis is supported within the American society.

Reference List

Adler, F., Mueller, G. O. W., & Laufer, W. S. (2012). Criminal justice: An introduction. (sixth ed.). Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Gehrke, P. J., & Keith, W. M. (2014). A century of communication research: The unfinished dialog. New York., NY: Routledge.

Gold, L. H., & Simon, R. I. (2015). Gun violence and psychological sickness. Opa-Locka, FL: American Psychiatric Publishing.

Falkof, N. (2015). Satanism and household homicide in late Apartheid South Africa: Imagining the top of whiteness. New York, NY: Springer.

Hartley-McAndrew, M., & Crawford, D. (2016). A commentary on autism and ethical growth: What can we study from the Sandy Hook School capturing? North American Journal of Medical Science, 6(3), 1–7.

Kaszeta, D. (2014). CBRN and hazmat incidents at main public occasions: Planning and response. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons.

Large, M. M., Ryan, C. J., Callaghan, S., Paton, M. B., & Singh, S. P. (2013). Can violence danger evaluation actually help in medical decision-making? Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 48(3), 286-288.

Maxfield, M., & Babbie, E. (2014). Research strategies for legal justice and criminology (2nd ed.). Stamford, CT: Cengage Learning.

Meloy, R. J., & Hoffmann, J. (2013). International handbook of risk evaluation. Boston, MA: OUP USA.

Paterson, B., McIntosh, I., Wilkinson, D., McComish, S., & Smith, I. (2012). Corrupted cultures in psychological well being inpatient settings. Is restraint discount the reply? Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 1(1), 1-16. Web.

Stevens, H. (2013). Crime and psychological issues. Aarhus C: Aarhus University.

Looking for this or a Similar Assignment? Order a Paper Now